A walking encyclopedia Auto companies and their tech partners are betting AI chatbots belong on your car dashboard—ready to answer questions about your route or the next rest stop in a hands-free, natural back-and-forth conversation. But does that same idea make sense when you’re on foot or on a bike? That’s what Google is banking on with its Gemini-powered navigation. As a carless pedestrian and cyclist, I gave it a try in a few different cities on both coasts. Credit: Brittany Holloway-Brown, Photos: Adobe Stock, Google My first impression? I found it hard to get over the awkwardness of speaking aloud to an AI on the street. “What neighborhood am I in?” I tried to discreetly mumble into my phone on a crowded Manhattan thoroughfare, as instructed by Google’s blog post. It did unfailingly know the right answer, though. Its knowledge of local trivia was encyclopedic too; Gemini could tell me all about why Mayor Fiorello La Guardia established the Essex Market, for instance (to crack down on pushcart vendors). And it was well-versed in local stores and restaurants. But when it came to adjusting routes based on these conversations, the app tended to struggle. At one point, it added 13 miles and a tour of a neighboring city to my walking route because it misunderstood a trail. For me, I’d skip the hassle of trying to coax the AI voice into tweaking directions. The local fun facts can be entertaining, but I’d rather just google it later. Then again, I’m not the sort of person who’s inclined to ask Siri to do things for me in the first place. Read my full review here. The Good: Gemini’s knowledge of local trivia tidbits and stores or restaurants is spot on, and it’s very in tune with your surrounding environs. The Bad: It often struggled to turn the routes it describes aloud into actual directions within Google Maps. Maybe it’s personal preference, but the experience of talking aloud to an AI on the street is not for me. Verdict: Noise —PK |