Is the world too polarized to revive Lilith Fair?
 

MAY 7, 2026

 

A LONG TALK

Sarah McLachlan Is Waiting to Pass Her Torch Is the world too polarized to revive Lilith Fair? “One could argue that’s all the more reason to do it.”

By Devon Ivie

“I’m happy to be a part of it. I’m happy to offer any advice if I can if I’m asked. But the younger generation needs to carry it forward now.” Photo: Steve Granitz/WireImage

Lilith Fair was born out of a desire that came from being in a weird, lonely job. Sarah McLachlan, having an epiphany about how poorly female musicians were treated in the 1990s, took it upon herself to create a festival where they could share the same stage together and prove their collective power in the industry — with a bonus being that “a lot of us have truck-driver mouths, and we’re able to have a really good time without pretense or preciousness or hierarchy.” The traveling music festival had three successful iterations in 1997, 1998, and 1999, and its history and legacy is documented in Hulu’s Emmy-eligible film, Lilith Fair: Building a Mystery. (McLachlan is joined by a dream blunt rotation of feminists including Sheryl Crow, the Indigo Girls, Bonnie Raitt, and Olivia Rodrigo.) But an attempt to recapture that magic by reviving the festival in 2010 was a failure, which McLachlan believes is enough evidence to prove it would be a relic of a bygone era if it were attempted in 2026.

“I think it would be very threatening to a large demographic,” she says. “It would be very enticing to a large demographic too, but it’s an incredibly polarizing world right now. One could argue that’s all the more reason to do it, but that wasn’t the reason to do it in the first place.” If Lilith Fair somehow returned from its mythological grave, McLachlan is emphatic that a new torchbearer would have to do the work to make it happen. But will anyone take her up on the challenge?

READ MORE

Subscribe now to get unlimited access to everything New York, including subscriber-only newsletters, exclusive perks, the New York app, and more.

Subscribe Now
 

News Feed

Celebrity gossip, industry updates, and beyond.

➼ Sul sul, Mr. Bridgerton. 

➼ Mark Ruffalo wants state attorney generals to block the Paramount-WBD merger.

➼ Tonight's the night.

 

ADVERTISER CONTENT

 
Learn more about OpenWeb
 

Joel Kim Booster Supports Millennial Cringe

This week on Good One, Joel Kim Booster returns to talk about joining the cast of Scrubs, why he thinks you could never make Fire Island today, and more.

WATCH
 

Today in Culture

Ron Taylor Was Ready for Everything Except Winning Funny AF

“Everybody’s like, ‘Oh, man, I always knew!’ I’m like, ‘That’s crazy, because I didn’t!’”

Ron Taylor Was Ready for Everything Except Winning <em>Funny AF</em>

 

The Man Who Made Cable Cool

Ted Turner placed a series of big bets on a nascent TV industry — and reshaped pop culture along the way.

The Man Who Made Cable Cool

 

We Got the Old Kacey Back

Musgraves recommits to country with her most compelling Texas-rooted album since her breakthrough.

We Got the Old Kacey Back

 

The Dark Wizard’s Unconquerable Contradiction

The HBO docuseries can’t settle on an answer for why Dean Potter was the way he was, but it’s riveting to watch it try.

<em>The Dark Wizard</em>’s Unconquerable Contradiction
 

Latest TV Recaps

  • Survivor Recap: It’s Splitsville
  • The Valley Recap: Rollercoaster Relationships
  • The Boys Recap: The Natural Order to Things
  • The Testaments Recap: Magic Eyes
 

Vulture Games

Play the latest Cinematrix, Telematrix, and crossword.