The Book Review: The dishiest, juiciest novel of the season
Plus: new books we loved this week.
Books
September 18, 2026
This is a photograph of Deesha Philyaw.
Ysa Pérez for The New York Times

Dear readers,

If you’re going to name a short story after a dessert, you probably couldn’t do better than peach cobbler. There’s a reason that Deesha Philyaw has built a cult following around her story “Peach Cobbler,” which arrives midway through her award-winning collection “The Secret Lives of Church Ladies.”

It’s funny, sensual and bittersweet. The narrator thinks her pastor, with whom her mother is having an affair, is God himself based on the cries she hears behind the bedroom door during his visits. It’s also an ideal introduction to Philyaw’s work, which burrows into the interior lives of God-fearing women trying to reconcile their desires with their faith.

With her first novel, Philyaw is working in an entirely different mode — outrageous, snarky and satirical. “The True Confessions of Lady Freeman,” which comes out on Sept. 29, follows Scharisse, the wife of a megachurch pastor in Georgia. Her husband is wealthy and powerful, tending to a congregation the size of a public university, but Schar, as she’s known, is still trying to earn the esteem of her fellow “first ladies.” The novel’s climax is a pageant for these women to compete in terms of holiness and wholesomeness, but Schar takes a very different path to the stage than she had planned. (Think a striptease with a symbolically loaded apple.)

I spent four leisurely hours in Miami with Philyaw last month talking about motherhood, ambition, disappointment and pleasure. They’re all of a piece for her, and she doesn’t shy away from life’s messiness in her fiction. Betrayal, infidelity and hypocrisy are rampant in the novel, along with devastating comebacks and a whole lot of sarcasm.

Philyaw, it turned out, has been living with Schar as a character for two decades. They matured together and learned to grieve in tandem. Knowing this back story adds a poignant dimension to “True Confessions.” Even for a novel so over the top and undeniably juicy, it has a very tender heart.

I’ll see you next week.

Like this email?
Sign-up here or forward it to your friends. Have a suggestion or two on how we can improve it? Let us know at books@nytimes.com. Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

LOOKING FOR YOUR NEXT BOOK TO READ?

Editors’ Choice

5 New Books We Love This Week

Reading recommendations from critics and editors at The New York Times.

We hope you’ve enjoyed this newsletter, which is made possible through subscriber support. Subscribe to The New York Times.

THIS WEEK IN THE BOOK REVIEW

THE BOOK REVIEW PODCAST

Four books, one yellow, one orange, one brown and one blue, standing, each separate from the others, on a light yellow surface against a darker yellow wall. "The Book Review" is written in white on the top left, and a "T" logo for the The New York Times is on the bottom.

The Book Review

John Green Knows a True Hollywood Ending is Complicated

The author discusses writing his first novel for adults.

play button

57 MIN LISTEN

ETC.

This is an illustration of Anthony Jeselnik.

Rebecca Clarke

By the Book

Anthony Jeselnik: Men Should Think of Reading as ‘Lifting Weights for Your Brain’

But the comedian isn’t naïve when he makes selections for his popular book club: “Most importantly, they’re short.”

An illustration of a typewriter with the NYC skyline sticking out instead of a sheet of paper.

Ben Hickey

Can You Identify These Places That Nurtured Writers?

Poets and authors have long found inspiration around New York City. Try this quiz to see how many locations you recognize.

A composite illustration shows a detail from the cover of Jerry Pallotta’s first Who Would Win? book, “Killer Whale vs. Great White Shark,” in the top left-hand corner, plus details from the covers of five books by other authors that might appeal to fans of the series.

The New York Times

Children’s Books

My Kids Love the ‘Who Would Win?’ Books. What Should They Read Next?

Ten recommendations for fans of the mega-popular dueling-animals series.

By Travis Jonker

BEST SELLERS

If you received this newsletter from someone else, subscribe here.

Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance.

You received this email because you signed up for Books from The New York Times.

To stop receiving Books, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings.

Subscribe to The Times

Connect with us on: