Migration targets vary, but all get the same thing wrong

AU Edition - Today's top story: Australia has 3 competing migration policies. The problem? None are based in evidence

October 15, 2026

AU Edition

 

Migration has been in the news almost all year, but rarely more so than in the past month. Since September 14, One Nation, Labor and the Coalition have all announced policies on the topic, offering up a bevy of figures, rules and mooted solutions.

With all the numbers floating around, you’d be forgiven for not knowing which party wants to do what and when, let alone how their proposals compare.

Migration expert Peter McDonald has done the hard work for you, explaining what these policies have in common and how they diverge.

Despite the many differences, McDonald writes that all three share a focus on one particular metric to measure migration. Unfortunately, this number is among the least helpful for making evidence-based policy in the national interest.

 

Erin Cooper-Douglas

Public Policy Editor

 
 

Australia has 3 competing migration policies. The problem? None are based in evidence

Peter McDonald, The University of Melbourne

One Nation, the Coalition and Labor have all released migration plans in the last month. How do they compare to one another?

It’s no secret drug firms donate to political parties. But it’s still a secret exactly how much, and why

Deborah Gleeson, La Trobe University; Barbara Mintzes, University of Sydney; Cassandra de Lacy-Vawdon, La Trobe University

Donations of A$7.7 million over a decade have been disclosed. But that’s not the full amount, a new study shows.

How the ‘digital duty of care’ bill could undermine vital sex and drug education online

Isabelle Volpe, Curtin University; UNSW ; Daniel Reeders, Australian National University; Kate Seear, Deakin University; Kath Albury, Swinburne University of Technology

Safety messages about drugs and sex are already routinely misidentified and removed from social media platforms. The proposed bill would take this further.

Senate throws out budget plan to remove health insurance top up for older people

Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra

The Senate has rejected the government’s controversial budget measure to cut the private health insurance rebate for people 65 and older.

View from The Hill: everyone is on the lookout for Albanese-Chalmers tension

Michelle Grattan, University of Canberra

The ins and outs of the Albanese-Chalmers relationship is in the wider context of positioning for succession.

Australia urgently needs a national bushfire database. Here’s what it could look like

Nader Naderpajouh, University of Sydney; Matt Duckham, RMIT University; Raghad Emran, University of Sydney; Soniya Rijal, University of Sydney

Bushfires will only become fiercer and more frequent in the face of climate change.

School teachers are burning out at alarming rates. How can we help keep them happy in their jobs?

Luke Aaron Tomlin, The University of Western Australia; The Kids Research Institute Australia

Supporting teacher wellbeing means more than stepping in once they are already overwhelmed and ready to leave the profession.

NAZA: harrowing documentary shows how killing in Gaza became just another day’s work

Ayesha Jehangir, UNSW

Directors Yuval Abraham and Rachel Szor offer us a look inside the systems used by the Israeli military to target Palestinians.

Renters and home buyers are seeing AI-‘enhanced’ property photos. Now NSW is changing the rules

Paul Harrison, Deakin University

Renters and homebuyers have been turning up to properties to find a very different reality from the ads. There’s even a name for it: ‘housefishing’.

Hordes of yabbies are trashing rivers in Africa. How did this happen?

Rachael King, South Australian Museum

In the 1980s and 1990s, the hardy redclaw crayfish was exported from Australia around the world. But escapee yabbies have become a nightmare.

Politics + Society

Environment + Energy

Science + Technology

Arts + Culture

Books + Ideas

  • What was Australia’s first novel?

    Maggie Nolan, The University of Queensland

    A riches to rags tale written by a convict was published in Hobart in 1830. On mainland Australia, an Irish widow published a gothic melodrama in 1838.

Your Say

I agree with Jim Chalmers’ warning to those on the progressive side of politics not to 'scold' or 'mock' potential One Nation voters, but instead to take seriously the task of persuading them away from the insurgent party. In 2016, Hillary Clinton paid dearly for calling Trump supporters 'deplorables'. Politicians need to be visible, open to discussion, and willing to woo rather than boo potential One Nation supporters.

— Elizabeth Mackenzie
Read the article

I was reading your piece, ‘Invasive species do much more damage in Australia and NZ than elsewhere. But why?’, and it reminded me of a parks and wildlife officer in South Australia who, some 20 years ago, suggested that the loss of dingoes as predators had contributed to the lack of natural control over kangaroo populations. He noted that kangaroos remain in plague proportions due to reduced population-control activities, including hunting by both 'settlers' and Aboriginal people. Foxes, much maligned, were suggested as a compensating factor, filling the void left by dingoes. It makes one wonder what other introduced species might help establish a balanced ecosystem. Rather than selectively exterminating species that could be useful, perhaps we should consider alternative strategies.

— Angelo Morella, Athelstone SA
Read the article
 

We'd love to hear from you.

Each day we publish an edited selection of your views on our stories.

Email us
 
 

Featured Events, Courses & Jobs

View all
Canberra Writers Festival

15 - 18 October 2026 •

The Future of Quantum

21 October 2026 • Carlton